Editorial Decision Process
EDITORIAL DECISION-MAKING
Editorial Decision Process
Transparent, impartial and scientifically justified manuscript decisions.
Editorial decisions at CRJPAS are intended to reflect the scientific merit, methodological quality, originality, ethical compliance and disciplinary relevance of submitted manuscripts.
Editorial Decision Categories
ACCEPT
The manuscript satisfies the journal's scientific and editorial requirements and is approved for publication, subject to any remaining routine production and integrity checks.
MINOR REVISION
The manuscript requires limited corrections or clarifications that do not fundamentally change the study design, principal findings or conclusions.
MAJOR REVISION
Substantial modifications are necessary, potentially involving methodological clarification, additional analysis, improved interpretation or major restructuring. A revised manuscript may undergo another round of external review.
REJECT
The manuscript does not satisfy the journal's requirements concerning scientific validity, originality, methodological rigor, ethical compliance or relevance. A rejection decision does not imply misconduct unless specifically stated and supported by evidence.
Initial Editorial Rejection
The handling editor may reject manuscripts without external peer review when they are outside the journal's scope, substantially incomplete, insufficiently original or clearly unsuitable for scholarly evaluation.
Evaluation of Reviewer Recommendations
Reviewer recommendations are advisory. Editors assess the substance and quality of reviewer reports rather than relying exclusively on the number of positive or negative recommendations.
Revisions and Reassessment
Authors submitting revised manuscripts should provide a point-by-point response to reviewer comments, identify relevant changes and explain any recommendations they have not adopted.
Revised manuscripts may be assessed by the original reviewers, additional experts or the handling editor, depending on the nature of the revisions.
Final Editorial Authority
The final acceptance or rejection decision is made by the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized independent decision-making editor.
Individuals responsible for article-level editorial decisions must not allow publication fees or commercial considerations to influence their decisions.
Appeals
Authors may submit a reasoned appeal identifying potential factual errors, procedural concerns or significant scientific information that was not adequately considered.
Appeals should be evaluated by an editor without a relevant conflict of interest. Reconsideration does not guarantee reversal of an editorial decision.
Post-Acceptance Concerns
Acceptance does not prevent the journal from investigating material concerns that arise before publication, including potential research misconduct or serious errors affecting scientific integrity.