Peer Review Policy
SCIENTIFIC QUALITY ASSURANCE
Peer Review Policy
Maintaining scientific integrity through independent, rigorous and transparent manuscript evaluation.
1. Introduction
The Current Research Journal of Pharmaceutical and Allied Sciences (CRJPAS) recognizes independent peer review as a fundamental mechanism for ensuring scientific quality, methodological rigor, academic integrity and the reliability of published research.
The journal's peer review policy is designed to ensure that manuscripts are evaluated fairly, objectively and confidentially by qualified specialists with expertise relevant to the submitted research.
2. Peer Review Model
Double-Anonymized Peer Review
CRJPAS applies a double-anonymized peer review model to research manuscripts. Under this arrangement:
- Reviewers do not receive the authors' identifying information.
- Authors do not receive the identities of reviewers.
- Editors maintain access to the information required for editorial administration.
- Confidentiality is maintained throughout the review process.
3. Independent Expert Evaluation
Research manuscripts that pass initial editorial assessment are normally evaluated by at least two independent expert reviewers who are not members of the journal's editorial office and who possess appropriate knowledge of the manuscript's scientific field.
Additional reviewers may be invited when specialist methodological, statistical or disciplinary expertise is required.
4. Reviewer Selection
Reviewers are selected according to their academic expertise, research experience, independence, professional qualifications and ability to provide a constructive scientific assessment.
Editors must identify and manage potential conflicts of interest before reviewer assignments are confirmed.
5. Evaluation Criteria
Reviewers are expected to assess manuscripts according to the following criteria:
- Originality and scientific contribution.
- Relevance to pharmaceutical and allied sciences.
- Clarity of research objectives and hypotheses.
- Appropriateness of study design and methodology.
- Validity of data analysis and statistical interpretation.
- Reliability and reproducibility of reported findings.
- Appropriate research ethics and reporting standards.
- Consistency between results and conclusions.
- Relevance and accuracy of cited literature.
6. Editorial Decisions
Following evaluation, the handling editor may recommend acceptance, minor revision, major revision or rejection.
The Editor-in-Chief or an authorized decision-making editor has final responsibility for the editorial decision. Reviewer recommendations inform but do not automatically determine the outcome.
7. Confidentiality
All manuscripts, unpublished research findings, supplementary materials and reviewer reports are treated as confidential scholarly communications.
Reviewers must not disclose, distribute or use unpublished manuscript information for personal or professional advantage.
8. Publication Ethics
CRJPAS does not permit manipulation of peer review, fabricated reviewer identities, undisclosed conflicts of interest or inappropriate influence over editorial decisions.
Suspected misconduct is addressed through documented editorial procedures and relevant publication ethics principles.
9. Special Issues and Editorial Content
Research articles published in special issues are subject to the same independent review standards as regular research submissions.
Editorials, corrections, retraction notices and other non-research content may receive editorial assessment rather than external peer review. Any exception must be transparently identified.
Our Commitment
CRJPAS is committed to independent scientific evaluation, fair editorial decisions, research integrity and responsible scholarly communication.