Reviewer Guidelines

GUIDANCE FOR PEER REVIEWERS

Reviewer Guidelines

Professional standards for independent, constructive and responsible peer review.

1. Role of Peer Reviewers

Peer reviewers contribute specialized scientific knowledge to the editorial evaluation of manuscripts submitted to CRJPAS.

Reviewers are expected to provide objective, constructive and evidence-based evaluations that assist editors in making informed decisions and help authors improve the quality of their research.

2. Acceptance of Review Invitations

Before accepting an invitation, reviewers should consider their subject expertise, availability and potential conflicts of interest.

Reviewers should decline assignments that fall outside their area of competence or cannot be completed within the agreed period.

3. Scientific Assessment Criteria

  • Originality: Does the research make a meaningful scientific contribution?
  • Relevance: Is the manuscript consistent with the journal's aims and scope?
  • Methods: Are the study design and procedures scientifically appropriate?
  • Statistics: Are the analytical methods suitable and correctly interpreted?
  • Results: Are findings presented accurately and transparently?
  • Discussion: Are interpretations supported by evidence?
  • References: Are the cited sources relevant and appropriately represented?
  • Ethics: Are relevant ethical approvals and declarations provided?
  • Reproducibility: Is sufficient methodological information supplied?

4. Structure of the Review Report

A professional review report should normally contain:

  1. A brief summary of the manuscript's principal contribution.
  2. An assessment of its scientific strengths.
  3. Major concerns requiring substantive revision.
  4. Minor comments concerning clarity and presentation.
  5. Recommendations concerning methodology, data and interpretation.
  6. A confidential recommendation to the editor.

5. Constructive Scientific Feedback

Reviewer comments should be respectful, specific and actionable. Criticism must focus on the scientific content rather than the personal characteristics of the authors.

Requests for additional experiments or analyses should be justified by their relevance to the manuscript's central conclusions.

6. Confidential Comments to the Editor

Reviewers may communicate confidential concerns to the editor, including suspected misconduct, undisclosed conflicts of interest or substantial methodological weaknesses.

Important scientific criticisms should also be communicated constructively to authors whenever appropriate.

7. Timeliness

Reviewers should complete their evaluations within the agreed period and notify the editorial office promptly if an extension is required.

8. Use of Artificial Intelligence

Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts, figures, supplementary files or unpublished research data to external generative AI systems.

Any proposed use of AI-assisted tools in the review workflow requires prior editorial authorization and must comply with the journal's confidentiality and disclosure requirements.

9. Final Recommendation

Reviewers may recommend acceptance, minor revision, major revision or rejection. Final editorial decisions remain the responsibility of the journal's authorized editors.

Reviewer Commitment

Professional peer review must be independent, confidential, scientifically informed and directed toward improving the accuracy and reliability of scholarly literature.