Peer Review Process

EDITORIAL WORKFLOW

Peer Review Process

From initial submission to editorial decision and publication.

CRJPAS follows a structured editorial evaluation process intended to maintain scientific quality, transparency and accountability at every stage of manuscript assessment.

SUBMISSION

↓

INITIAL EDITORIAL SCREENING

↓

REVIEWER ASSIGNMENT

↓

INDEPENDENT PEER REVIEW

↓

EDITORIAL EVALUATION

↓

REVISION / ACCEPTANCE / REJECTION

↓

PRODUCTION AND PUBLICATION

Stage 1. Manuscript Submission

The corresponding author submits the manuscript and required supporting files through the journal's official Open Journal Systems (OJS) platform.

Authors must provide accurate metadata, authorship information and relevant ethical declarations.

Stage 2. Initial Editorial Screening

The editorial office verifies manuscript completeness, journal scope, formatting requirements, originality declarations and research ethics documentation.

The Editor-in-Chief or handling editor determines whether the manuscript is suitable for external scholarly evaluation.

Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's requirements may be returned for correction or rejected without external review.

Stage 3. Reviewer Assignment

Qualified reviewers are selected according to disciplinary expertise, methodological competence and independence.

Research manuscripts normally require at least two independent external expert reviews.

Stage 4. Independent Peer Review

Reviewers assess the scientific originality, methodology, data analysis, interpretation, ethical compliance and scholarly significance of the manuscript.

Reviewers provide structured comments and recommendations through the authorized editorial system.

Stage 5. Editorial Evaluation

The handling editor evaluates the reviewer reports and may request additional expert assessment when recommendations are substantially divergent or additional methodological expertise is required.

Stage 6. Editorial Decision

The manuscript may receive one of the following decisions:

  • Accept
  • Minor Revision
  • Major Revision
  • Reject

Stage 7. Author Revision

When revisions are requested, authors must submit a revised manuscript and a detailed, point-by-point response explaining how each reviewer and editor comment has been addressed.

Revised manuscripts may be returned to reviewers for further assessment.

Stage 8. Final Decision

The Editor-in-Chief or authorized decision-making editor determines whether the manuscript meets the journal's scientific and ethical standards.

Stage 9. Publication Preparation

Accepted manuscripts proceed to copyediting, proofreading, layout preparation, metadata verification and final production checks.

Stage 10. Publication

The article is published in the journal's official publication system with the approved bibliographic details and applicable access and licensing information.

Editorial Transparency

Peer review is an evaluative process and does not guarantee acceptance. Scientific quality, research integrity and editorial independence remain essential at every stage.