Review Model
INDEPENDENT SCIENTIFIC EVALUATION
Review Model
Double-Anonymized Peer Review and protection of scholarly independence.
STANDARD REVIEW MODEL
DOUBLE-ANONYMIZED
Author identities are concealed from reviewers, and reviewer identities are concealed from authors.
Purpose of the Review Model
The double-anonymized model is intended to reduce potential bias associated with author identity, institutional affiliation, academic seniority, geographical location or professional reputation.
Although anonymization cannot eliminate every potential source of bias, it establishes an additional safeguard supporting fair scientific assessment.
Author Anonymity
Authors must prepare an anonymized manuscript that does not disclose identifying information in the main text, document properties, acknowledgments, supplementary files or other material supplied to reviewers.
Identifying information should be supplied in a separate title-page file accessible to authorized editorial personnel.
Reviewer Anonymity
Reviewers' identities are not disclosed to authors during the evaluation process. The editorial office maintains the information required to verify reviewer qualifications and manage conflicts of interest.
Number of Reviewers
Research manuscripts normally undergo assessment by at least two independent external reviewers. Additional expert opinions may be requested when necessary.
Selection and Independence
Reviewers must possess expertise relevant to the manuscript and must disclose relationships or circumstances that could compromise impartiality.
Preprints and Anonymity
Where preprints are permitted, authors should disclose the existence of relevant preprints. Publicly available preprints or identifying manuscript details may make complete anonymity impossible.
Confidentiality and Review Reports
Reviewer reports and correspondence are treated as confidential. Reviewer identities and unpublished review reports are not made public without the required authorization and applicable consent.
Final Editorial Authority
The Editor-in-Chief or authorized decision-making editor retains final responsibility for acceptance and rejection decisions, taking reviewer recommendations and the complete scientific record into account.
The journal does not permit fabricated reviews, impersonation of reviewers, manipulation of the reviewer selection process or undisclosed conflicts of interest.