Reviewer Ethics

PUBLICATION ETHICS AND INTEGRITY

Reviewer Ethics

Ethical responsibilities, confidentiality and independence in scholarly evaluation.

1. Ethical Principles

Peer reviewers are expected to uphold high standards of scientific integrity, impartiality, confidentiality, professional conduct and accountability.

Reviews must be based on scholarly evidence and should not be influenced by personal, commercial, institutional or other inappropriate considerations.

2. Confidentiality

Submitted manuscripts are confidential scholarly communications. Reviewers must not disclose manuscript content, unpublished data, figures, methods or editorial correspondence to unauthorized persons.

Reviewers must not retain or reuse confidential materials for purposes unrelated to the authorized review.

3. Conflict of Interest

Reviewers must disclose actual, potential or perceived conflicts of interest before accepting an assignment.

Examples include recent research collaboration, financial relationships, personal relationships, institutional involvement and professional competition that may compromise objective evaluation.

Where a significant conflict exists, the reviewer must decline the assignment or follow the handling editor's instructions.

4. Scientific Objectivity

Reviewers must evaluate the manuscript according to its scientific content, methodological quality, relevance and ethical compliance.

Discriminatory comments, personal criticism, unsupported allegations and unprofessional language are unacceptable.

5. Research Misconduct

Reviewers who identify potential plagiarism, fabricated data, duplicated publication, inappropriate image manipulation or other suspected misconduct should communicate their concerns confidentially to the editor.

Reviewers should describe the basis of their concerns without independently contacting the authors or initiating unauthorized investigations.

6. Citation Ethics

Reviewers must not request unnecessary citations for personal benefit or attempt to manipulate journal or author citation statistics.

Recommendations to cite additional literature should be supported by clear scientific relevance.

7. Assistance and Co-reviewing

Reviewers must not delegate manuscript assessment or share confidential documents with colleagues, students or other individuals without prior permission from the editorial office.

Any authorized contributions to the review must be acknowledged to the editor.

8. Artificial Intelligence and Confidentiality

Confidential manuscript materials must not be entered into public or third-party AI systems. Reviewers must obtain prior authorization before using any AI-assisted technology in their review activities.

AI-generated assessments must not substitute for independent expert judgment.

9. Breaches of Reviewer Ethics

Suspected breaches of confidentiality, undisclosed conflicts of interest, inappropriate use of manuscript content or manipulation of peer review may result in withdrawal of reviewer assignments and further action under the journal's approved procedures.

Ethical Reference

The journal's reviewer ethics principles are informed by recognized international recommendations on responsible peer review, including guidance from COPE and ICMJE.